| Study | ARRIVE Guideline | ||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Methods | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Title | Abstract | Background | Objectives | Ethical statement | Study design | Experimental procedure | Experimental animals | Housing/husbandry | Sample size | ||||||||||||
| a | b | a | b | c | a | b | c | d | a | b | a | b | c | a | b | c | |||||
| Li [21] | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | P | P | F | P | F | N | F | P | F | F | N | F | N | NA |
| Liu [22] | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | P | P | F | P | F | N | F | P | F | F | N | F | N | NA |
| Wang [23] | F | F | F | F | F | N | F | P | P | F | P | P | N | P | P | P | F | N | F | N | NA |
| Li [24] | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | P | F | F | N | F | N | NA |
| Du et al. [25] | F | P | F | F | F | F | F | P | P | F | P | P | N | F | P | F | F | N | F | N | NA |
| Li et al. [26] | F | P | P | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | P | P | P | N | F | N | NA |
| Li et al. [27] | F | P | P | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | F | F | N | F | P | P | P | N | F | N | NA |
| Liu et al. [28] | F | P | P | P | F | N | F | P | P | F | P | P | N | F | P | P | P | N | F | N | NA |
| Liu et al. [29] | F | P | P | N | F | F | F | P | P | F | P | P | N | F | P | P | P | N | F | N | NA |
| Du et al. [30] | F | P | P | N | F | N | F | P | P | F | P | P | P | F | P | P | P | N | F | N | NA |
| Study | ARRIVE Guideline | ||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Methods | Results | Discussion | |||||||||||||||||||
| Allocating animals to experimental groups | Experimental outcomes | Statistical methods | Baseline data | Numbers analyzed | Outcomes and estimation | Adverse events | Interpretation/scientific implications | Generalizability/Translation | Funding | ||||||||||||
| a | b | a | b | c | a | b | a | b | a | b | c | ||||||||||
| Li [21] | P | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | F | P | P | F | N | ||||
| Liu [22] | P | N | F | F | F | N | F | F | NA | F | N | N | F | P | P | F | F | ||||
| Wang [23] | P | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | P | N | N | F | N | P | F | F | ||||
| Li [24] | P | N | F | F | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | F | N | P | F | F | ||||
| Du et al. [25] | P | N | F | P | F | N | P | F | NA | F | N | N | F | F | P | F | F | ||||
| Li et al. [26] | F | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | P | N | N | N | F | ||||
| Li et al. [27] | F | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | F | N | N | F | F | ||||
| Liu et al. [28] | P | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | NA | F | N | N | F | N | F | F | F | ||||
| Liu et al. [29] | P | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | F | N | N | N | F | ||||
| Du et al. [30] | P | N | F | P | F | N | F | F | P | F | N | N | P | N | P | N | F | ||||
ARRIVE, Animal Research: Reporting In Vivo Experiments; F, fully reported; P, partially reported; N, not reported; NA, not applicable.